Boxes so good, you'll think they're stolen.

Hand-packed from truckloads of Amazon, Walmart & Target returns and overstock. Retail value beats what you pay.

Shop Mystery Boxes How it works

4.6 from 811 reviews
1,660,228 lbs kept from landfills
Pick up in Lexington

As featured on

NBC
CBS
ABC
barchart
NewsNet
openPR

Pick your tape

Each tape color is a different chase item. Every box is packed with real retail merchandise.

Shop all boxes

How the loot gets to you

The full rundown

Step 1: We buy truckloads
Returns, shelf-pulls and overstock from major national retailers.
Step 2: We hand-pack your box
18 × 16 × 12 in, sorted by tape color. Every box gets a serial number.
Step 3: You unbox & share
Retail value beats what you pay. Post your haul and tag us.

Real crew, real hits

Share your haul

Pirates are talking

Rated 4.6 out of 5 from 811 reviews

Read all 811 reviews

Rated 5 out of 5Sep 27, 2026
I loved the box but........I received a bottle of shampoo, that had opened up and spilled on all the clothes and a few of the boxes. I washed the clothes but was not able to teybthe shampoo.
Rebecca S.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Sep 23, 2026
Awesome things, something didn't make sense, others were perfect for my home! I let my kids and grandkids look thru, if they find something they like they got. These boxes were really good this time!! I will be back as soon as I can.
Rebecca S.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 4 out of 5Sep 19, 2026
Pictures because the video with two grandkids was a little hectic. They have been waiting for these boxes. In the box several items. Dishwasher cleaner, steel glove for kitchen use, Stitch pjs, derivation night light, grout tile marker, box of Christmas...
Nicola B.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Sep 16, 2026
The box was pretty good. Clothes, accessories, small inflatable pool, auto scratch paint (actually matches my car), couple auto accessories, and my favorite thing was United Stated of America 250 full size flag. I will be ordering again.
Margaret A C.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Aug 14, 2026
My husband and I had so much fun looking through our mystery box! We got seasonal hand towels, a 250th Anniversary flag, a pair of women’s pants, socks, a couple yard flags, a chair seat cover and more. The quality of the products is top notch. We can’t wait...
Sheri O.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Oct 28, 2025
LOVE getting the mystery boxes from Porch Pirates!
Brenda
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 4 out of 5Oct 27, 2025
I got a Micheal Kors Purse and an expensive board game that my bf enjoys! Got a pretty good box, the rest of the stuff wasn’t very useful.
Autumn G.
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Oct 24, 2025
What a great mystery box!!! 10/10 would recommend, and will buy again!!!
Shanon J.
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Oct 5, 2025
I just received my first mystery box and I am very happy with it. Thr best part is I was literally talking to my husband about how I wanted to get myself a daily devotional journal and lo and behold, there was one in this box. I do recommend exercising some...
Sherrie S.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 4 out of 5Oct 3, 2025
Pleasantly surprised. Some things I would never use but can sell readily.
Anonymous
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Sep 24, 2025
I'm in love with these boxes!! I got a $200 brand new Skims bathing suit in this box!! Not to mention everything else! Ive ordered lots of these boxes from other sites and this company wins hands down! Can't wait to order more! #Goldenticketgiveaway
Addyson L.Verified buyer
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance
Rated 5 out of 5Sep 23, 2025
Can not wait to receive my next box and I got a golden tickets!!!
Shannon Y.
Reviewed Blue Tape Mystery Box - PS5 Chance