Returns
Return & refund policy
Porch Pirates' Industry-Leading Return Policy
Every Porch Pirates mystery box is designed to deliver surprise, excitement, and incredible value. Occasionally, however, a box may be mishandled during shipping or an item may arrive damaged or defective.
When a legitimate issue occurs, we'll work to make it right.
This policy covers mystery boxes we ship to you. Anything bought in person or picked up is final sale; see our In-store & pickup purchases policy. Wholesale, pallet and truckload orders follow their own quote or invoice.
Contact Us Within 30 Days
If your order arrives damaged or contains a defective item, contact us within 30 days of delivery. Our Customer Care team will review the issue and guide you through the return process.
What You'll Need
Please email the following information to support@porchpirates.us:
- A clear photo of the outside of the shipping box
- For Classic Series boxes, a photo of the unique box ID (serial number) printed inside your box. Our other boxes don't have one; your order number and photos are enough.
- Photos of the damaged or defective items
- Your order number and a brief explanation of the issue
Once the information has been reviewed, we'll provide return instructions and, when applicable, a return authorization.
Help With a Carrier Claim
If your box was damaged in shipping, we'll help you file a claim with UPS (or whichever carrier delivered it). Please keep the shipping box and all packing materials until the claim is settled, because the carrier may ask to see them.
Return Shipping
Customers are responsible for return shipping costs. This allows us to continue offering exciting products and exceptional value in every mystery box.
Refund or Replacement
Once your approved return has been received and inspected, you may choose between:
- A full refund to your original payment method, or
- A replacement mystery box at no additional product cost
Yearly Return Limit
Each customer can return or replace up to 3 mystery boxes, with up to $1,000 in total retail value inside them, in any 12-month period. The 12 months count back from the date of your new request, and returns from before this limit was posted count too.
Retail value means the regular retail price of the items inside the returned boxes, not what you paid for the boxes. We set it from your photos and the items you send back, and our decision on it is final.
Boxes damaged in shipping do not count toward this limit. A box counts as damaged in shipping when your photo of the outside of the shipping box shows the damage and we confirm it with the carrier. Every other approved refund, replacement or return counts.
We count the limit per customer, and we may treat people as one customer when they share a household, address, payment method or account, or when we reasonably believe they are buying together. Our decision on this is final.
Once you reach the limit, we will not refund, replace or accept a return on any other box until your 12-month count drops below it. Boxes damaged in shipping are still covered.
Return Integrity and Limitations
Porch Pirates reserves the right to deny a return or exchange when required documentation or items are missing, the request falls outside the return period, or there is evidence of misuse, fraud, or repeated return activity.
We may also restrict future purchases associated with individuals, businesses, payment methods, or addresses involved in repeated or abusive return requests.
Shop With Confidence
Mystery boxes should feel exciting, not risky. Our return policy gives you added peace of mind knowing that our team is here to help when a legitimate problem occurs.
Questions? Contact our Customer Care team at support@porchpirates.us.